Menu: Greek Pan Pizza, Pasta & Subs, Sarasota | Eleni's

Eleni’s Pizza Works Menu — Greek-Style Pizza, Pasta & Salads, Sarasota

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4.6 stars · 1,600+ Google reviews

Family-owned and operated since 2004, Eleni’s Pizza Works has been Sarasota and Bradenton’s neighborhood favorite for the best pizza in the area. Our signature Greek-style pizza starts with 24-hour slow-proofed dough, hand-stretched and pan-fried in olive oil for a golden, crispy crust you simply won’t find anywhere else — or order our classic hand-tossed New York-style if that’s your tradition. Beyond pizza, we serve Italian classics like lasagna, shrimp scampi, and chicken parmesan, fresh salads with house-made dressings, and burgers from our half-pound patties. Generous portions, fair prices, and the same family recipes for over two decades.

🍕 Pizza

Our signature Greek-style pizza is born from 24-hour slow-proofed dough, pan-fried in olive oil for a golden, crispy crust unlike anything else in Sarasota. Generous toppings, fresh mozzarella, simmered marinara — the way Eleni’s family has made it since 2004. Classic NY-style hand-tossed also available.

Large Cheese Pizza$16.49
Large Pepperoni Pizza$18.98
Pepperoni Deluxe (pepperoni + extra cheese)$22.49
Happy Greek (feta, olives, onion, tomato)$22.99
Meaty Meat (sausage, meatball, pepperoni, bacon)$26.99
Shrimp Scampi Pizza$24.99

🍝 Pasta

Italian classics done right — our pastas are cooked to order, sauces simmered daily. From hand-rolled meatballs over spaghetti to shrimp scampi tossed in white wine and garlic, every plate is a generous portion at a fair price. Comes with garlic bread and a choice of soup or salad on full plates.

Spaghetti & Meatballs$15.99
Lasagna$16.99
Shrimp Scampi Spaghetti$17.49
Chicken Parmesan over Pasta$17.49
Eggplant Parmesan$17.99

🥦 Salads

Crisp, fresh salads tossed with our house-made dressings. The Greek is the favorite — feta, olives, peppers, red onion, cucumber, tomato, on romaine, finished with oregano and olive oil. Add grilled chicken or gyro meat to turn any salad into a full meal.

Garden Salad$8.49–11.99
Greek Salad$9.99–12.99
Caesar Salad$7.99–10.99
Antipasto$10.99–13.99

Add grilled chicken or gyro meat +$2.99 medium / +$3.99 large

🍔 Burgers & Sandwiches

Half-pound hand-formed burgers, grilled to order on a brioche bun; the platter comes with fries. Italian and Greek-inspired sandwiches — the chicken parm sub is a fan favorite, the Italian sub is loaded, and our gyro platter is a Sarasota staple with house-made tzatziki on warm pita.

Cheeseburger$12.99
Cheeseburger Platter (with fries)$16.99
Chicken Parm Sub$12.99
Italian Deluxe Sub$12.99
Gyro Platter$16.99

🥟 Appetizers

From crispy garlic breadsticks brushed with butter to golden mozzarella sticks, our appetizers are made fresh. Try the Wings — eight flavors including our signature Greek lemon-oregano — or the Spinach Pie folded in flaky phyllo.

Garlic Breadsticks$8.49
Mozzarella Sticks (6)$9.99
Chicken Wings (8)$13.99
Spinach Pie$13.99

🍰 Desserts & Drinks

Save room — our tiramisu and homemade baklava (the Greek heritage shining through) are made in-house. Fountain soda, fresh-brewed iced tea, plus a curated list of house wine and craft beer for dine-in guests at our Sarasota dining room.

Tiramisu$7.99
Baklava$6.99
Cheesecake$6.49
Fountain Drink$2.99

🥑 Catering

Feeding a crowd? Eleni’s caters across the Sarasota–Bradenton area — pizza party trays, pasta hotel pans, salads, Italian classics for office lunches, graduations, birthdays, and game days. Call (941) 758-8700 or visit our catering page for menu & pricing.

Catering: standard delivery within 4 miles of our kitchen, further out confirmed by phone —
see full catering menu & pricing

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4.6 stars · 1,600+ Google reviews

Sarasota and Bradenton’s favorite pizza for over 20 years

🍕Order Online
🛒Order Now 📞Call 📍Directions
Scroll to Top